My vote would go for one of the Nikon Buckmaster II scopes in the 4-12x. Great glass for the money and great eye relief.
Yes Nikon makes a nice scope. I have a Buckmaster on a Ruger 243 and it works well. Even hit the concrete once with no ill effects. Love my Nikon SLR camera too.
My Redfield is crystal clear but has a cheap overall feel compared to Nikon.
You can use whatever on a 17 cal. There is no recoil.