bcm vs noveske in the department of accuracy

[sajnaj]

i was able to compare the differences between a noveske rifle and a bcm both rifles were fired unsupported except for the magazine touching the shotting table the bcm belonged to me and noveske belonged to dialtone301.

the first rifle was a spikes lower with a mill spec trigger, bcm upper 16 carbine light barrel, vortex strike fire for a optic and it was firing wolf wpa 62 grain hp

the second rifle was a noveske rifle 16 inch barrel mid length with geissele trigger ssa and a eotech for a optic. i believe it was firing a brass cased 55 grain fmj

 

[Stainer]

Windy day? What was your distance?

 

[AllenM]

Any day shooting is a good day

But, 2 different types of ammo? would be nice to try same ammo in each upper from a rest to get a better idea of difference in uppers accuracy.

What was the distance being shot?

 

[nipprdog]

But, 2 different types of ammo?

And one of them being Wolf??????

Not a good test at all.

 

[shavedforbattle]

Both BCM and Noveske are excellent rifles. I'm willing to bet that if you did a proper accuracy test, with a shooting rest and the same ammo, you wouldn't see a very big difference in accuracy.

 

[esrice]

Both BCM and Noveske are excellent rifles. I'm willing to bet that if you did a proper accuracy test, with a shooting rest and the same ammo, you wouldn't see a very big difference in accuracy.

This.

Glad you got out to do some shooting though!

 

[sajnaj]

100 yards

 

[flatlander]

And one of them being Wolf??????

Not a good test at all.

Your "comparison" proved nothing other than both rifles will go bang with that ammo.

Bob

 

[Cerberus]

Like said above for a good comparison you need to use something to provide support and use the same ammo. Gotta elliminate to variables.

 

[tdoom15]

Like others have said, you need to eliminate a lot of those factors, maybe use the noveske lower and swap the upper with same ammo, shooter, and optic.

That being said, Noveske is well known for their accuracy over some of the other top tier manufacturers...esp their SS barrels. Is the noveske SS or CL?

 

[shavedforbattle]

I always hear how Noveske makes pretty much the most desirable barrel on the market. Maybe someday I will have the coin to find out if the talk is true.

 

[DialTone301]

The Noveske is chrome lined.

In his defense it wasn't meant to be a formal test. He asked if he could shoot my rifle and compare it to his. I told him sure but use my ammo since I wasn't sure what he was shooting.

 

[sajnaj]

And these two rifles were in the 300 rounds in 28 seconds and in my opinion these two rifles performed flawlessly out of the bunch