Dave's Metal Works, Sure-Cycle and Nordic Components tube are all top quality.
I just switched to a Nordic on my Benelli and it wasn't because of a tactical-looking tube nut. It has the best fit and finish of the group and is made and designed by shooters for shooters. The +5 extension will stick out ~1.5 inches past the end of your barrel. It isn't a problem from a function standpoint.
My vote would goto Nordic, but I've been known to like things that are over engineered, and way over built.... You know like something you could take to the end of the earth....