Best pizza in Evansville

[johntheplinker]

I like Turroni's a lot but the pizza market in Eville seems overwhelmed with the very thin crust, square cut style pizza (St Louis style?). I wish there was a greater variety of more traditional hand tossed pizza purveyors.

Unfortunately this. Never cared much for the super thin crust. I'll take Papa John's over the cracker crust stuff any day.

 

[MrAverage]

Evansville must not have a Casey's gas station based on these responses.

 

[Informed Decision]

Personally, I prefer the thin crust. Not into eating a bunch of bread.
I've never had any gumption to try any thing from Casey's but , they are in town. May need to step outside the box.
I am still looking for a good place besides Highland Pizza. I feel there's a mom & pop place out there somewhere for a good take home pizza.

 

[a.bentonab]

Is here any place with Chicago style deep dish? I've had the double decker at deerhead but I'm looking for something else.

 

[atvdave]

Have you been to Old Chicago on the east side?