I'm ok with it either way. I look at it like tattoos. If it's for you and if you are 100% sure of what you want then get it. If you need input from everyone else then your not ready and your getting it because of or for them.
If you like the tattoo great, if you don't I apologize I accidentally gave you the impression I cared. JMO
Laser engraving would work for something like that, it is a bit shallow but can be filled with silver or gold...or paint if you are doing it on the cheap. I have had knife blades laser engraved at Stoops in Kokomo, did a very nice job.