G43 or LC9S

[SouthernStar25]

The quintessential win/win situation. I own both and IMHO you can't go wrong with either one.

 

[Dyerbill]

The quintessential win/win situation. I own both and IMHO you can't go wrong with either one.

Agree 100%

 

[bonkers1919]

Call a few gun ranges and see if they rent both guns and test them side by side. If you can't test both of them at the same time, write down the pluses and minuses of each gun you're testing.

Go home, feet up, ESPN baseball, adult beverage, and compare your notes. If you are still torn about which gun test them again but in reverse order.

Let the little voice in your head be heard......Buy once, cry once.

 

[wildcatfan.62]

"LC9s, LCP
Shield 9, Shield 9 Performance Ctr (with the ported barrel/slide- you CAN feel the difference)
Glock 43
...and a few others

ALL of these can be rented at Point Blank in Carmel
$10 at the rental counter- shoot all day

Pappy"
I did want Pappy suggested in Goshen at a different shop -Shoot to Thrill. I tested the Shield, G43 and LC9S all at the same time. It's a great way to determine which fits your hand and that you shoot the best. After two range trips I settled on the LC9S Pro (left handed -didn't want the safety). YMMV but I just shot it better. Best of luck you can't go wrong with either. I've bounced all over the place trying to find the "best" carry for me. So far it's been a fun journey glad to live in a free state in America where we get to make these types of choices.... now if I can just convince Mrs. Wildcatfan.... Good luck!

 

[gglass]

This is a pretty cool video of the Glock 43 suppressed. Looks like a fun little setup.

https://www.full30.com/video/ae7ba9f4c8903cf98c67d163909e2d15

The reviewer is a die hard Glockster, and does say that he would probably buy the Shield if he had it to do over again due to some issues with the G43. Just sayin'.

 

[shooter521]

Shot 'em both, own the G43 (x2). Grip ergonomics feel better to me, and the Glock has a lower bore axis so perceived recoil is diminished; in fact, the G43 seems to recoil the least of all the single-stack 9mms I've shot (Shield, PPS, LC9S, XDS, 938, PF9, 709, P9/PM9). Ruger has a nicer trigger (longer pull than the Glock, but lighter and smoother) and is less expensive. Figure out what your priorities are and which gun best meets your needs.

 

[indyff]

I would stick with the same platform of your primary gun. I do love the glock 43 but it's a little snappier than the 42.

 

[JACKD7]

Both are about the same size and price. If you have glocks then that seems to be the way to go.

 

[Never A Victim]

Glock 43-talk to someone who teaches people how to shoot for a living. He will not say good things about Ruger LC9/LCP/etc.

 

[Hornett]

LC9 --> Very Bad

LC9s --> Redesigned striker fired, Very Good

An LC9 is NOT the same as an LC9s

 

[Yojimbo229]

Same here, BK.
...and on a functionality note, I put Taran +2s on two mags and cheaped out with the $10 Pearce extensions on my remaining four mags. Pearce is good for a little extra pinky real estate, cheap...why not?
However, try a tap/rack with a Pearce and yowchie owie blood blister.
Tarans are well worth it for the weight and flat design they provide. Mr."buy once cry once" had to relearn his own mantra and buy a couple more every couple months! Not cheap but well worth it.

p.s. the stronger replacement spring is really helpful when adding the +2

I run Tarrin Tactical +2 round extensions on my G43 to get past the short grip issue.

As for the OP... like someone said- that's up to your hand and personal preference. The LC9s trigger is a hyuuuuuge improvement over the LC9. Personally, fit and feel of the Ruger is not for me.

 

[minuteman32]

I have both an LC9S Pro & a G43. I shoot the 43 better & there are a LOT more aftermarket things for it (sights, holsters, etc.). I like both of them, though.

 

[Yojimbo229]

I have both an LC9S Pro & a G43. I shoot the 43 better & there are a LOT more aftermarket things for it (sights, holsters, etc.). I like both of them, though.

This is what makes Glock the 500lb gorilla it is. ...along with being damn fine quality, simple and safe.

If you want to know your car will make the run in December at 0300 for the 2yr old's fever do you want to get a Jag? Try getting parts at the local PepBoys, let alone the cost once parts are obtained. (yes, yes, there are Jags -and Kimbers...and probably a Yugo somewhere- which have run like butter for years....no need to talk 'possible' v. 'not unlikely')
Parts and accessories for Civics are practically available at 7-11....and we're talking going to the store; not 100yd shots on a lazy, sunny day or bullseye comps.

Ruger isn't as difficult as HK or CZ re: getting a holster (with a light, especially) but the options and variety aren't as ubiquitous as Glock, either. It really is a selling point when the pistol decision between two guns is neck and neck. If ya gotta gotta gotta have that LH9-MKii with a TLR-3...well you've made your bed and are happy to take your lumps when needing extra mags, a holster etc.
Ruger is a great brand and I've had few problems w/ them (great service). I've had far far fewer with Glock.

Now, someone explain "mixed metaphors" and the meaning of "ubiquitous" for this ol' boy!

Ruger:Glock is close to apple:apples. I bet you'll be happy with whatever fits your hand/body the best.

 

[HamYankee]

I would like to see a poll added to this.

 

[SheepDog4Life]

G43 or LCS9/Pro

Throw in the M&P Shield and I face exactly the same conundrum. Whichever of these I happen to be fondling at the moment feels really good in my hand. Bascially, too many good choices has led to gridlock on my part. Yep, I over analyze purchases, it's what I do.

I wish there were someplace in the Evansville area that rented these guns so I could shoot all three. No joy so far.

 

[pack-indy]

Another happy G43 owner here.

 

[looney2ns]

Being the Glock 43 is really really close in size to a Ruger Sr9c, buy the 9c.

 

[blue2golf]

G43 or LCS9/Pro

Throw in the M&P Shield and I face exactly the same conundrum. Whichever of these I happen to be fondling at the moment feels really good in my hand. Bascially, too many good choices has led to gridlock on my part. Yep, I over analyze purchases, it's what I do.

I wish there were someplace in the Evansville area that rented these guns so I could shoot all three. No joy so far.

Call up Right to Bear Arms in Haubstadt right off US41. They might have at least one of those to rent to use on their indoor range.

 

[OVERTHEHILLGUY]

I have shot my G43 over 1,000 rds, no problems, great pistol!

 

[jb1911]

I've owned both, still own the G43. It's a no brainer choice.