And again the caveat, every hiring person is different.
yup, and many times the ones who do the initial scanning are in HR, not an IT guys. These days most companies have resumes submitting online and keyboards are scanned for.
Not having the basic certs will cut you out of many consulting and contracting firms that may let a newbie get some experience.
I've been an MCSE since NT 3.51 and was the original Active Directory architect out at Eli Lilly but ended up victim to outsourcing 14 months ago. Even with tons of experience, everyone I interviewed with were still looking for updated certs, which I hadn't bothered to keep up with after Server 2000.
I'm with you, we shouldn't need them, as one who went thru having to find a new job, I still think the more you have to start, the better.