P250 compact vs. G19 or M&P

[jag09]

I'm looking for a new edc pistol. I am a pretty small framed guy 5'7" and 145lbs, before I was carrying a Ruger P89dc, but found for everyday carry that it was very heavy. I've seen plenty of reviews of the G19 and M&P,but haven't really heard much on the Sig P250 as an edc.

Any sugguestions as to which would be better as an edc, or other suggestions for below $600?

 

[Glock10MM]

I'd go with a G19 or a M&P 9C. I didn't really care for the Sig 250 but, YMMV.

 

[JimmyR]

I had a sig 250, but I didn't keep it too long. It was good for what it was, but not my favorite gun. If I were going to get a polymer 9mm (to play second fiddle to my cz75), I'd look at the m&p.

 

[jag09]

JimmyR- What is your current edc? My first choice is between the G19 and MP, i've shot the g19 but haven't had the chance to shot the M&P yet

 

[kawtech87]

Im a Sig guy but Ill tell you the P250 is crap compared to other Sigs.

If you want a cheap, relaible, polly Sig look into the SP2022.

I voted G19 btw.

 

[JimmyR]

I carry a cz75bd most of the time, but if I need to cc I carry either a kahr cm9 or a smith and wesson 642.

 

[Barista]

I voted M&P9 but would highly suggest the M&P9c. If you are smaller framed then you have the nice option of replacing out the backstraps from S/M/L

 

[jag09]

The grip isn't really a problem, as the Ruger I had wasn't no means small and the G19 fits quite comfortable in my hands.

 

[DustyDawg48]

Of the 3, Glock 1st and then the M&P9 2nd. I am a huge fan of both platforms and the edge goes to Glock in a few areas but they are both a fantastic gun. If you can shoot either/both before buying, do so and go with the one you like the best. Holsters for the Glock will be more plentiful and you'll be able to find accessories much easier for the Glock than the Smith but they are both top-notch choices.