thoughts on edc gun?

[prduke]

Currently have an xd9, but thinking about a smaller gun for edc. Any opinions on which one? Single stack like a kahr? Or a subcompact like a glock 26 or a 3" Springfield? I love my springfield, but did not know about the double stack. Would a single stack be better? Thanks

 

[Turn Key]

First, welcome to INGO bro ..

Second, seriously consider a Glock. If you want 9mm in a sub compact, look at the Glock 26. Glock makes a great mag extension called their +1. But in 9mm this extension will give you 2 more rounds. So, a G26 with 12+1 is a force to contend with ..

JMO,

~TK

 

[spencer rifle]

Kahr CW9. Sometimes forget I have it with me. My own family did not realize I had it on me last time I carried. Not too expensive. Reliable (after break in, but I buy mine used on INGO after someone else has done that for me). Fits well in hand. Kicks less that my PF9. Good stuff.

 

[Plinkuh]

Sihg P239 is a great choice, and hey, whatta ya know, there's one in the classifieds!

 

[Takashi]

imho, the one that you are able to shoot well and will carry most often is your best bet. If your xd9 is too big, then go smaller. I like the G26.

 

[IN_Sheepdog]

Walther PPS

My EDC's are an M&P 40 (two big, if CC. Open Carry is fine) or a Keltec P3-AT, (too small) so I have been looking for that in between (and the Baby Bear said, "This one is Jusssst Right.")
Biggest issue for me is the double stack as it seems the grip and the big magazine have much more to do with visibility, than the physical size of the rest of the gun.
I am also looking for something that has more punch than the .380 round.

I would agree that the Kahr CW9 is a good possible choice and one I have been looking at, but I also really liked the Walther PPS, as it is VERY flat, lightweight and is available in either the 9MM or .40 Cal, striker fired (Ie, pull gun,point, and it goes bang,... I am always concerned being accustomed to the M&P that I will in a stress situation overlook the external safety)

Or, I have also been looking at the Kimber CDP II, or Crimson carry (in either the Pro 4" or Ultra 3") models. My Keltec 3-AT has the laser switch in the same position and having a smaller gun (with very short sight radius), I am a strong believer in the point shooting with the laser in a stress situation. Very little argument with a dot on the target, backed up by a .45 cal.
The issue with the Kimber as always is the price, but what is the price when you are counting on the thing to be used to save your butt, and are going to be hauling it around day in and day out. I also have looked at the model with the rounded heel, but as far as I know they do not have the laser grips for that model... Guess that is really what I am holding off for. Of course, once you are back to the Kimber with the .45 single stack, physically the piece starts getting almost as large as what you are carrying now.

 

[jgreiner]

Currently have an xd9, but thinking about a smaller gun for edc. Any opinions on which one? Single stack like a kahr? Or a subcompact like a glock 26 or a 3" Springfield? I love my springfield, but did not know about the double stack. Would a single stack be better? Thanks

another option is to look at the S&W MP 9c.....

I have the MP pro with the 5" barrel, love it, full size 1911 owners tell me that carrying comfortably is all about he belt and holster......so i am looking at this holster down the road.

 

[jgreiner]

Currently have an xd9, but thinking about a smaller gun for edc. Any opinions on which one? Single stack like a kahr? Or a subcompact like a glock 26 or a 3" Springfield? I love my springfield, but did not know about the double stack. Would a single stack be better? Thanks

Also the Ruger LC9 might be a good option.....

 

[EdC]

I've found that barrel length (up to 5"), makes the least difference as to concealability and comfort, and I'm short (about 5'5").

For me, width is no. 1 factor, grip length is no 2, and overall loaded weight a very close no. 3.

Sounds like a single stack 9 is what you might want to explore. Kahr and Walther are two that come to mind.

 

[prduke]

thx

Thanks for the replies. Will look at some of those suggested!

 

[TVon]

If you like your XD9, try the same in sub-compact. I carry my XD 40 SC all the time with no problems and I'm a skinny guy. It's pretty much the same size as the Glock 26/27 everyone else is mentioning.

 

[shortyforty]

i like the glocks 23/27,but i am surprised no body has mentioned a j frame revolver small easy to use good firepower can be had in .357 mag and reliable

 

[EvilElmo]

If you like your XD9, try the same in sub-compact. I carry my XD 40 SC all the time with no problems and I'm a skinny guy. It's pretty much the same size as the Glock 26/27 everyone else is mentioning.

+1. I carry an XD9sc in a supertuck with no problems at all with a loose t-shirt. With the exception of the barrel and grip length the 9sc has the exact same dimensions as the full size XD9, and with the extended mag the grip is the same length too.

If you prefer the changes made on the XDm line the new 3.8 inch compact models look nice.

 

[eldirector]

Would a single stack be better?

Better than what?

I'd first find out what feels good in your hand, and that YOU can shoot well. Then pick which one of those works best in your EDC method (OC or CC).

My Springfield XD40SC seems to work fine for me. I shot the standard XD40 and liked it, so picked up the sub-compact version to carry. If you are trying to conceal, a good holster is at LEAST as important as the gun. My SuperTuck goes a long way towards making that XD disappear.

 

[bw210]

Everybody has their preference and I have carried many from compact Glocks, XD's and various revolvers from 38 to 44spl. The last three years I have carried an SA EMP40 and have held nothing that I would replace it with. Totally reliable, eats anything I feed it, very slim, easy to conceal and shoot and is a tack driver for a 3".

Besides choosing your side arm, you will also need a quality dual ply gun belt and a good holster, otherwise you'll own something you won't carry. I use TTGunleather holsters and two belts, TTG and Beltman dual ply with stiffener.

 

[BountyHunter]

Do These make my butt look big?

Everybody has their preference and I have carried many from compact Glocks, XD's and various revolvers from 38 to 44spl. The last three years I have carried an SA EMP40 and have held nothing that I would replace it with. Totally reliable, eats anything I feed it, very slim, easy to conceal and shoot and is a tack driver for a 3".

Besides choosing your side arm, you will also need a quality dual ply gun belt and a good holster, otherwise you'll own something you won't carry. I use TTGunleather holsters and two belts, TTG and Beltman dual ply with stiffener.

I'm sorry, that just came to my mind, when I seen the pics.
But on a serious note that is a great looking setup you got there(holster and mag holster) that is.

 

[marshallartist]

I've found that barrel length (up to 5"), makes the least difference as to concealability and comfort, and I'm short (about 5'5").

For me, width is no. 1 factor, grip length is no 2, and overall loaded weight a very close no. 3.

Sounds like a single stack 9 is what you might want to explore. Kahr and Walther are two that come to mind.

For me grip length is #1, width #2 and weight #3. That's why I love to shoot the XD pistols but I carry a Glock 19. The 26 is a little easier to conceal and slightly more comfortable to carry but only by a small margin. The XD sc models are no more comfortable/concealable than the G19 so I just don't see the point although I really like the XDM9c with the 3.8-inch barrel.

 

[Sigman]

Make sure you are taking a close look at the weight and size when shopping for an EDC. A few ounces makes a huge difference. Many people start leaving their EDC behind because it becomes to uncomfortable for them to carry daily. Its also important to understand how you plan to carry, such as the type of holster setup. Just some food for thought.

 

[Toolepqk]

Also the Ruger LC9 might be a good option.....

I carry the lc9, it's a great size for conceal and so far I've had no problems with mine. 950 rounds through it.

 

[9mmfan]

First, to . Second, you need to find out what fits your hand best and what you shoot best, no matter what the caliber (within reason). It is no use buying a Colt Government Model and then find out you can't hit anything with it or that you have to wear a shirt 2 sizes too big to conceal it(if CC).