Where is your favorite pizza place?

[terrehautian]

My favorite is Bazbeaux Pizza and I love the garlic cheese bread and quattro pizza there.

 

[dmarsh8]

Mine
seriously. Sometimes I'l make one with pesto and vine or Roma tomatoes, satay some baby portabellas........... And so on

 

[Jomibe]

So Italian in Brownsburg makes a good pie.

 

[Double T]

Oley's or my wife's homemade deep dish

 

[edporch]

Nancy's Pizza in Fishers.

The best Chicago Style pizza I've found in the Indy area.

 

[whiskeytangofoxtrot]

Maurizios in Terre Haute or Giordanios in Chicago.

 

[dwh79]

Xtraordinary Pizza in Wanamaker, IN

 

[Sullivan_pbr]

Bruno's in Logansport

 

[findingZzero]

Sal's pizza 103st and Broadway, NYC (moved from 96st and Broadway many years ago). A stand up joint (in the sense of being very narrow). This was pizza that didn't need anchovies, beef and pineapple to have flavor. The flavor was in the cheese and sauce. When you folded it (you had to fold it or it would flop down-see the opening for Louis C.K.s show) the buttery oil would run down the fold and drip..OMG! Fugeddaboudit.
Years ago, Luca pizza approached this. Most NYC pizza was that good, but Sal's was a bit better. The price went from .25 to $2/slice over the years. The first pizza I remember in NYC was in the '50's off a truck. This stuff was foreign to us and we had to Bart Simpson mom to get us some. We all (kids) had diarrhea that night......mom chuckled.

 

[Magneto]

Tony Impellizzeri's Pizza in New Albany on Charlestown Road. Best pizza I have had and I have been eating it for 20 years. The bread sticks are the best in existence.

 

[Bunnykid68]

Closed many many moons ago. PizzAroma in Evansville. Damn I miss that place

 

[giovani]

Pizza king, any one of them.

The one in Geneva is especially good!

 

[BuckeyeBrad]

I hear from many friends that the Ordinary in Wanamaker and the Willard in Franklin have the best around. I have yet to try either though. So for me I will have to say Mug 'N Pye out in Monrovia.

 

[forgop]

Xtraordinary Pizza in Wanamaker, IN

Great stuff. Plan on it taking 45 minutes to get your pizza. I may just have to ask the Mrs to bring one home after church.

Love Giordanos as well.

 

[hornadylnl]

Had one at the Ordinary. Wasn't anything special in my opinion. Crust was like those fundraisers buy for schools, etc. They piled the toppings on insanely high. Kind of like the bigger the tenderloin, the better it tastes theory.

 

[dsol]

Best I have had in the area, the New Albanian (formally called Rich-O's) in New Albany, off Grantline road near the Krogers. Insane beer list from all over the world, and great pizza to go with.

Best I have ever eaten, some little hole in the wall place across from the airport in Miami. They made their own crust and sauce and it was surpurb. I need to fly down there just to get one if they are still open.

 

[Kernal1984]

Pizza king is king for American pizza in my book but for real deal pizza nothing better than Rocky's in Flagler Beach FL.

 

[voodoo304]

+1 Bruno's in Logansport. I could eat that every darn day. I haven't found anything in Indy that even comes close. Too bad I'm 2 hours away now. But when I do get it, it tastes oh so good.

 

[terrehautian]

Pizza king, any one of them.

The one in Geneva is especially good!

I like the sandwiches at PK, I worked at one for a short time. I do like the one in Avon because of how they deliver your drinks (model train).

 

[hornadylnl]

+1 Bruno's in Logansport. I could eat that every darn day. I haven't found anything in Indy that even comes close. Too bad I'm 2 hours away now. But when I do get it, it tastes oh so good.

Is Bruno's that shack just east of the one way streets?