Which 9mm 1911?

[DadSmith]

I mean you could, but that sure is not going to be comfortable. I should state that I will continue to carry my G19 a majority of the time, but I love SA hammer guns. I guess by me saying I would carry it sometimes I was justifying spending that much on a pistol because it would be used often, but the reality is that it probably won't be. I just want to buy something nice for myself lol.

I carry a CZ P10F through the fall and winter. If in the woods I carry a 1911 10mm.
I've carried full size handguns iwb for many years with no problems.
Being 6'2" 225 I can hide full size handguns pretty easily. I'm sure police officer who knows what to look for would know, but your avg Joe or Karen wouldn't.

 

[dyerwatcher]

Hundreds of choices. I have had close to 20 over the years. For an all around option, I love my Wilson Combat Experior Double Stack 4”.

 

[Colt556]

The DWX is supposed to combine the good trigger of a 1911 with the grip and capacity of the CZ. It is a large pistol though and as others have said would be a challenge to EDC. I haven’t seen one in person but I have several CZs and 1911s and I get torn on which I like to carry the best. I love the 1911 Commander size and trigger but love the capacity and feel of the P01. I mostly carry the P01 but am still on the hunt for a LW Commander in 38 Super. I have a DW Guardian and Valkyrie but came to the conclusion they’re too nice to carry. IKR. The P01 is half the price and twice the capacity, plus I can carry spare mags that hold 18 rounds. I guess it’s like anything else and comes down to what works best for you at any particular point in time.

 

[BE Mike]

As someone who has carried a 1911 in the past, I'd recommend the "Commander" size over the full size. The little shorter barrel/ slide is easier to carry. I'd probably recommend a lightweight version, as well. A big heavy gun is a big temptation to leave at home after the newness wears off. Buying a "stock" pistol like the Colt Lightweight Commander will be far below your budget and to "personalize" it, you could send or take it to a competent pistolsmith to get upgrades you desire and still be below your budget. This one looks pretty nice: https://www.colt.com/detail-page/wiley-clapp-commander-9mm-bl

 

[migunner]

Always wanted a Dan Wesson Guardian in 9mm

 

[bsmithg19]

That Ed Brown in the classifieds sure looks nice!

 

[ChrisK]

The Staccato’s get rave reviews, but the double stack would be too wide for me to carry personally.

I carry a Staccato C2 with no issue at all. The new CS is a little thinner and the slide is a little shorter.

 

[redleg16]

My wife bought me this Ruger SR1911 target model for our 30th anniversary, it’s a great shooter, and she’s a great wife!

 

[DadSmith]

 

[Revo357]

I've been looking into 9mm 1911's also. I've shot a Springfield Range Officer in 9mm quite a bit and it's such a fun gun to shoot. I was also impressed by the factory trigger.

 

[dleak]

following this conversation myself
anyone have experience with bul ?
sas ii model if i recall

 

[spalfano]

For 1911, there are some great choices. Springfield 1911 DS Prodigy is pretty nice for around $1500. Stacatto if you really want a 2011 platform. It’s going to push your budget though. If you are open to used, you can certainly find a good Wilson Combat. I have heard Kimber is not as good as they used to be. I don’t know first hand so it’s just what I heard. If anyone here knows, chime in. Dan Wesson has options too that are in the budget. Let us know what you find and go with. Show and tell is encouraged!

 

[BE Mike]

For 1911, there are some great choices. Springfield 1911 DS Prodigy is pretty nice for around $1500. Stacatto if you really want a 2011 platform. It’s going to push your budget though. If you are open to used, you can certainly find a good Wilson Combat. I have heard Kimber is not as good as they used to be. I don’t know first hand so it’s just what I heard. If anyone here knows, chime in. Dan Wesson has options too that are in the budget. Let us know what you find and go with. Show and tell is encouraged!

I've also heard that about Kimber. She's the one that everyone votes for as prom queen, but not the one they'd pick to fly F-22's in defense of our country.

 

[Amishman44]

Hands down...'nough said!!!

https://www.gunbroker.com/item/963106355

 

[Bosbar]

The Springfield Garrison is a nice pistol for $800. or less.
I made a few adjustments to mine.

 

[DadSmith]

The best 1911 9m is a Sig p226.

 

[bloodandgutsmurphy]

Don't rule out a Hi Power

 

[DadSmith]

Rock Island 51615 GI Standard FS 9mm Luger Caliber with 5' Barrel, 10+1 Capacity, Overall Black Parkerized Finish Steel, Beavertail Frame, Serrated Slide & Black Rubber Grip

<p>The M 1911 GI Standard FS has fixed, low profile sights and traditional smooth slim design that is ideal for quick pull holster use. A durable black parkerized finish gives it a tough, smooth, non-reflective surface. The smooth wood grips offer comfort in both feel and design. The 5" barrel...

egunco.com

$300

 

[wcd]

Hands down...'nough said!!!

https://www.gunbroker.com/item/963106355

What about the 45 acp version? Wonder what recoil would be like with that light of a frame?

 

[wcd]

Rock Island 51615 GI Standard FS 9mm Luger Caliber with 5' Barrel, 10+1 Capacity, Overall Black Parkerized Finish Steel, Beavertail Frame, Serrated Slide & Black Rubber Grip

<p>The M 1911 GI Standard FS has fixed, low profile sights and traditional smooth slim design that is ideal for quick pull holster use. A durable black parkerized finish gives it a tough, smooth, non-reflective surface. The smooth wood grips offer comfort in both feel and design. The 5" barrel...

egunco.com

$300

$300?…