Which one would you choose?

[richardraw316]

G23 gets my vote

Almost there.

 

[Frosty]

I'll vote for the M&P. Plainfield shooting supplies had them a couple weeks ago for $499.

 

[peal1]

Go with the G23. The price is great and should provide a quick resale opportunity if you don't like it.

 

[rolodetective]

G23......I've had one for years. .40 is a good caliber, the size of the gun seems just right for concealed carry but also just right for doing the job when needed.
Check out Hickok45. He RAVES about his.