Pop's prices are not that bad on some guns, but sometimes depending on who's working you may get the cold shoulder. The best prices I have found are generally at one of these places:
In my opinion, probably the biggest reason to avoid Pops is their apparent...how shall I say it...lackluster support of 2A rights while dealing with the local media.
Other members here can confirm or deny at their leisure.
The blunt truth is that there are no really "good" gun stores in the Indy area. There hasn't been for years. Indianapolis is probably the worst-served large city in the Midwest for firearms.