Casey's General Store Pizza: OH, YES!

[lovemachine]

When microlovemachine gets some teeth, you should make that his first pizza experience.

I SHOULD do that. And he must try the garlic rolls.

 

[rhino]

Do I get credit for assigning the name microlovemachine to him, or did someone else beat me to the punch?

 

[lovemachine]

Do I get credit for assigning the name microlovemachine to him, or did someone else beat me to the punch?

Ha! Credit goes to you.

 

[fjw2]

Every morning, on the way to work, I get the bacon breakfast pizza. A week ago, I dropped it in my truck and it landed face down on the road atlas on the floor. All the bacon was in a nice, neat little pile. It was the best result of a bad situation. I called "five second rule" and salvaged it all. Yesterday, I dropped it again. This time it landed face down on my floor mat that is in desperate need of vacuuming. No nice little pile of bacon this time. It was everywhere. I still salvaged the the slice but swept the bacon bits out the door. When I got to work, I noticed one of the bigger bits of bacon was still on my running board. It is still there. Who knows, it might be there all winter. My wife says I need to be cut off from bacon pizza. I told her that's crazy.

 

[churchmouse]

There are 3 Casey's that were close to accounts I took care of when I was still running a service truck.
I enjoyed sitting in the store at the tables with the locals chowing on a few slices.
The subs were pretty good also.

 

[rhino]

Ha! Credit goes to you.

Score!

Every morning, on the way to work, I get the bacon breakfast pizza. A week ago, I dropped it in my truck and it landed face down on the road atlas on the floor. All the bacon was in a nice, neat little pile. It was the best result of a bad situation. I called "five second rule" and salvaged it all. Yesterday, I dropped it again. This time it landed face down on my floor mat that is in desperate need of vacuuming. No nice little pile of bacon this time. It was everywhere. I still salvaged the the slice but swept the bacon bits out the door. When I got to work, I noticed one of the bigger bits of bacon was still on my running board. It is still there. Who knows, it might be there all winter. My wife says I need to be cut off from bacon pizza. I told her that's crazy.

Your wife needs to stop with the crazy talk. And, more importantly, you need to be more careful with your breakfast pizza!

There are 3 Casey's that were close to accounts I took care of when I was still running a service truck.
I enjoyed sitting in the store at the tables with the locals chowing on a few slices.
The subs were pretty good also.

You are a good judge of pizza and subs, sir.

 

[chezuki]

I've heard this, but I've not been able to get past my "gas station pizza" assumptions to try it. There is one pretty close to us.

 

[dans4420]

Never would i eat a mexican pizza or taco pizza in my life..... Then my wife forced the caseys taco pizza on me it changed my life it took me to a place where pizza and tacos came together it was like a beautiful dream.

 

[oldpink]

I was spoiled at an early age with Top Hat, the one on Broad Street in New Castle, the only restaurant with that name from Pizza King.
Check out Clara's (the other Pizza King label) in Richmond on 5th Street, which has outstanding pizza, with the option to eat on an authentic English double decker bus.
I'm not kidding about that.

 

[Vigilant]

Caseys pizza is pretty good for "gas station" pizza! They are also one of the few places that actually make their own pizza dough, rather than topping up a frozen piece of card board!

 

[TB1999]

'll eat Casey's pizza for sure. Little greasy but still tasty!

 

[chubbs]

When Casey's first came to New Castle the boss brought some to the shop, Delicious!! Went a few weeks later to get one on a Saturday night, two meth heads picking at their faces behind the counter.......... Walked out and haven't been back since.

 

[miguel]

Morning after regrets, rhino?

Also, do they just have these pizzas waiting for customers or do you have to call ahead like a regular pizza place?

 

[rhino]

Morning after regrets, rhino?

Also, do they just have these pizzas waiting for customers or do you have to call ahead like a regular pizza place?

None! The leftovers are glorious!

They have slices ready all the time. Breakfast pizza in the morning, then a variety of others in the afternoon and evening.

 

[Alamo]

We stumbled upon Hunt brothers pizza in a gas station in Texas, pretty damn good!

This is true. I live out in the brush land of south central Texas, and the closest pizza is a general store that offers Hunt Brothers made-to-order pizza. Good stuff! The thin crust is really good, and a little lagniappe is that shooting targets (and bible verses) are printed on the box.

 

[MrsGungho]

Morning after regrets, rhino?

Also, do they just have these pizzas waiting for customers or do you have to call ahead like a regular pizza place?

I call ahead like a regular pizza place.

 

[fjw2]

Had their Canadien bacon and veggie breakfast pizza this morning. Can do without the black olives, but was still yumlicious!

 

[chezuki]

I've heard this, but I've not been able to get past my "gas station pizza" assumptions to try it. There is one pretty close to us.

I was late to the party on this. Best pizza in town period!

 

[churchmouse]

I was late to the party on this. Best pizza in town period!

When working in the small towns I have found a Caseys and had lunch. The subs are good enough and the Pizza is the same.

 

[rhino]

When working in the small towns I have found a Caseys and had lunch. The subs are good enough and the Pizza is the same.

They use meats that you can actually taste, unlike Subway!