I'm pretty sure you're just stirring the pot but...yes, lets be honest! Manning SUCKS! Always has always will.
Its HIS F ups that do his team in EVERY time...Picks and fumble sin the clutch..the guy just cant win the big games...The guy is not a choke artist, hes the KING of choke artists.
If you only look at Manning's post season stats, you have an argument, if you take his entire career, you're just as blind as the worshipers.